Another Look

I fell under the spell of this work written in 1975, a year before the premiere of the opera Einstein on the Beach. It was during this period that Philip Glass began to experiment with this repetitive style which made him one of the most unique composers of his time. I had the feeling, while listening to it, that this work modified our perception of time, abolishing the sensation of duration and plunging us into a state of hypnosis. It is also one of the rare large-scale non-religious pieces written for choir and organ. This singularity immediately aroused my interest and fueled my desire to approach this work with Les Métaboles, first of all through a new recording—of which there are few—which will be released in early 2025, then as part of a stage production created for the 2025-2026 season. Recently, I had the chance to direct several operas by Philip Glass, Einstein on the Beach and Akhnaten, and I could not envisage this choral piece without a stage contribution. Another Look is a radical work which is anchored in references to the music of the past (Gregorian chant and the School of Notre-Dame in particular). This piece was composed at a time when the porosity between the arts was very great, as such, bringing it a plastic dimension is a way of paying homage to this dialogue. This is the reason why I asked the pair Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul, from the company 14:20, so that they develop a plastic and audio-visual proposal constituting a whole with the music and thus participating in questioning the usual format of a concert.

Léo Warynski

ANOTHER LOOK


Philip Glass,
Another Look at Harmony Part IV

Andrea Basily,
Canon ad unisonum


Les Métaboles (18 singers)
Yoan Héreau or Denis Comtet, organ
Léo Warynski, direction

Céline Diez, scenography
Céline Diez & Clément Debailleul,
visual artists
Elsa Revol, light creation
Camille Pénager, costume design
Jeanne Crousaud, conseil artistique
Antoine Seigneur, technical director


Production Metaboles 
Co-production Cité de la Voix – National Center for Vocal Art and Cité musicale- Metz 
Another Look is supported by The Orange Foundation, Adami, Copie Privée and the CNM

Dans la presse

French conductor Léo Warynski, who revealed Another Look at Harmony, a youthful work by the American composer, last March, will conduct Satyagraha in Nice and Akhnaten at the Philharmonie de Paris in quick succession.

Libération - Eric Dahan - Another Look

His music compels us to rethink our relationship with time: in Paris and Nice, Léo Warynski conducts operas by Philip Glass

It’s the highlight of the new opera season: forty-five years after its world premiere in Rotterdam, the Nice Opera will present the French premiere of Satyagraha, Philip Glass’s second opera, inspired by the figure of Gandhi. A technically ambitious production (the audience will be surrounded by 360° video projections) and a programming choice that might seem bold if we didn’t know that the opera house’s director, Bertrand Rossi, is a fan of the American composer. In 2002, while he was at the helm of the Opéra du Rhin, Rossi presented the French premiere of Akhnaten. Five years ago, he inaugurated his tenure in Nice with a new production of the same work, entrusted to conductor Léo Warynski and actress, choreographer, and director Lucinda Childs, who rose to prominence in 1976 with Einstein on the Beach, the first installment, co-written with Bob Wilson, of Glass’s trilogy of portrait operas.

Although Paris has yet to see their magnificent Akhnaten, Léo Warynski will be staging it again on October 25 at the Philharmonie de Paris in a concert version. As for the promising Satyagraha, it is unlikely to be seen in the capital anytime soon, since another production, directed by Bobbi Jene Smith and Or Schraiber, is scheduled for April 2026 at the Bastille, marking the first time a work by Glass has been added to the Paris Opera’s repertoire. Finally, Léo Warynski will conclude this Glass season in December at the Philharmonie de Paris, where he will reunite with his choir, Les Métaboles, in Another Look at Harmony, a little-known work by the composer dating from 1975, of which he released a superb recording in March.

“Reading the score made me anxious”

Against all odds, it was while attending a lecture by Pascal Dusapin at the Louvre auditorium that Warynski discovered the leading figure of repetitive music, as he told us. “Dusapin had described how deeply moved he was by Einstein on the Beach, the sound of the organ, the choir, the visuals of the performance. Then he played a recording of the opening minutes of the opera. I never could have imagined that, years later, I would be conducting it at the Teatro Colón in Buenos Aires. What an experience! After the performance, I took a short walk to clear my head, but I couldn’t relax. I kept counting, in my head, the complex, haunting rhythms. I had jumped at the chance when it was offered to me, but then, as I read the score, I felt anxious, realizing the colossal task that lay ahead of me.”

Given that the Festival d’Automne invited Glass and his ensemble as early as 1973, and that the Cité de la Musique frequently featured his music in its programs, it is surprising that Warynski was taken aback by the difficulty of his works. “Glass remains unknown in French musical circles,” he replies. “I wasn’t told about him even once during my studies, whereas, in the late 1990s, Steve Reich’s City Life was on the high school graduation exam syllabus.”

“A Nightmare to conduct”

Léo Warynski always knew he would become a professional musician. In Colmar, where he was born on June 29, 1982, his mother, a gynecologist, sang and played the flute. His father, a child psychiatrist, played classical guitar when he came home from work. Noticing that he was fascinated by the sound of the cello, his uncle, a luthier, gave him one for Christmas. Before he was even 5 years old, the child was reading music and playing the instrument. At 6, he joined the Colmar choir, directed by Arlette Steyer. “I’ve fulfilled my desire to lead a group of singers or musicians,” he says, “because it’s a comprehensive profession that involves knowing all the facets of a work, proposing an interpretation, and knowing how to put together a concert program.”

At 18, he has been admitted at Lycée Fénelon, first in the hypokhâgne and then in the khâgne, specializing in music, and Paris dazzled him “with the promise of extraordinary encounters it offered.” There he studied harmony, counterpoint, and music history, alongside literature, Latin, and philosophy. Admitted to the Conservatoire national de musique de Paris, he studied orchestral and choral conducting under François-Xavier Roth and Pierre Cao. At 28, he founded Les Métaboles, an elite choir that collaborates with the Ensemble Intercontemporain, founded by Pierre Boulez. In 2014, he also became music director of the Ensemble Multilatérale, which had been founded nine years earlier by composer Yann Robin.

Having these two ensembles at his disposal allows him to produce high-caliber recordings and concerts, praised in these pages, such as Le Moine et le Voyou (2023), which juxtaposes Bernard Cavanna’s Messe un jour ordinaire with choral works by Francis Poulenc. In 2017, reading Paroles sans musique, Glass’s autobiography, captivated Warynski, who dreamed of conducting his Métaboles in one of his works. After several weeks of research, he commissioned the score for the rare Another Look in Harmony.

"The work foreshadows Einstein on the Beach. It is hellish to conduct and exhausting for the singers, who must train like athletes. It can be confusing if one doesn’t know that Philip Glass invented a new way of making opera in which meaning isn’t imposed: it’s up to the performers to sense the nuances that will allow the music to unfold, and to the listener to establish a connection between text and music, which are entirely independent. While it is no easy task to do justice to Glass’s sound, Akhnaten remains less radical and more romantic than Einstein on the Beach. One of the arias brings to mind a lament by Handel, and in Satyagraha, there is a soprano-alto duet that evokes that of Bach’s Cantata No. 4. What do I take away from the Glass operas I’ve conducted? His music, so rich, more maximalist than minimalist, compels us to push ourselves, physically and mentally, but also to renew our relationship with time, to free ourselves from the current dictatorship of immediacy.”

 

A reading that is both precise and free

Diapason - Benoît Fauchet
 - Another Look

A reading that is both precise and free

Diapason - Benoît Fauchet - Another Look

Onomatopoeia, repeated notes chanting their names, syncopations, and rhythmic disruptions… Another Look at Harmony Part IV, a movement for choir and organ lasting about fifty minutes, was a milestone in Philip Glass's career, foreshadowing his 1975 opera Enstein on the Beach.

Léo Warynski's Métaboles offers a reading that is both precise and free, almost lyrical, in a seamless dialogue with Yoan Héreau's keyboards. The combination with a 16-part canon by Andrea Basili, a little-known 18th-century composer, may be surprising, but prolongs the hypnosis very pleasantly.

A reading that is both precise and free

Diapason - Benoît Fauchet
 - Another Look

A reading that is both precise and free

Diapason - Benoît Fauchet - Another Look

Onomatopoeia, repeated notes chanting their names, syncopations, and rhythmic disruptions… Another Look at Harmony Part IV, a movement for choir and organ lasting about fifty minutes, was a milestone in Philip Glass's career, foreshadowing his 1975 opera Enstein on the Beach.

Léo Warynski's Métaboles offers a reading that is both precise and free, almost lyrical, in a seamless dialogue with Yoan Héreau's keyboards. The combination with a 16-part canon by Andrea Basili, a little-known 18th-century composer, may be surprising, but prolongs the hypnosis very pleasantly.

Sélection Le Monde - to listen to: the repetitive trend made in the USA

Le Monde - Pierre Gervasoni
 - Another Look

Sélection Le Monde - to listen to: the repetitive trend made in the USA

Le Monde - Pierre Gervasoni - Another Look

Mixed voices methodically reeling off a string of onomatopoeias and numbers, an organ – an electronic version – that ensures long sustains of notes, sometimes in the bass, sometimes in the treble… The characteristics of Enstein on the Beach, an opera created in 1976 by Bob Wilson with music by Philip Glass, also constitute the foundations of Another Look at Harmony. Part IV, a score of about fifty minutes composed a year earlier by the leader (with Steve Reich) of the repetitive trend made in the USA. However, we will be careful not to consider this page with its minimalist carillon appearance as a prelude to the stage work that has entered history since its creation at the Avignon Festival because it is very different from it from an aesthetic point of view. Particularly in the "overexpressive" interpretation of Métaboles (recorded live), which, far from the mechanical abstraction of Einstein..., makes it a sort of great hippie mass. The confrontation with the very soaring but rigorous Canon, by Andre Basili (1705-1777) then seems anecdotal.

Sélection Le Monde - to listen to: the repetitive trend made in the USA

Le Monde - Pierre Gervasoni
 - Another Look

Sélection Le Monde - to listen to: the repetitive trend made in the USA

Le Monde - Pierre Gervasoni - Another Look

Mixed voices methodically reeling off a string of onomatopoeias and numbers, an organ – an electronic version – that ensures long sustains of notes, sometimes in the bass, sometimes in the treble… The characteristics of Enstein on the Beach, an opera created in 1976 by Bob Wilson with music by Philip Glass, also constitute the foundations of Another Look at Harmony. Part IV, a score of about fifty minutes composed a year earlier by the leader (with Steve Reich) of the repetitive trend made in the USA. However, we will be careful not to consider this page with its minimalist carillon appearance as a prelude to the stage work that has entered history since its creation at the Avignon Festival because it is very different from it from an aesthetic point of view. Particularly in the "overexpressive" interpretation of Métaboles (recorded live), which, far from the mechanical abstraction of Einstein..., makes it a sort of great hippie mass. The confrontation with the very soaring but rigorous Canon, by Andre Basili (1705-1777) then seems anecdotal.

En vente sur le site

ANOTHER LOOK

New album
Live recording on January 11, 2024, at the Cité de la Voix in Vézelay

2027

May

Wednesday, May 19 2027 – 9:30 pmAnother LookTAP, scène nationale, Poitiers

By playing on the hypnotic repetition of floating motifs, minimalist music offers a fascinating sonic experience. This is the case with Another Look at Harmony, a sumptuous work by the American Philip Glass, the last part of which, for choir and organ, draws on references to Gregorian chant. Renowned interpreters of the music of our time, Les Métaboles and their conductor Léo Warynski are joined by scenographers and directors Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul to dedicate a captivating musical and visual spectacle to him.

Reservation

March

Saturday, March 20 2027 – 8:00 pmAnother LookThéâtre de Caen

By playing on the hypnotic repetition of floating motifs, minimalist music offers a fascinating sonic experience. This is the case with Another Look at Harmony, a sumptuous work by the American Philip Glass, the last part of which, for choir and organ, draws on references to Gregorian chant. Renowned interpreters of the music of our time, Les Métaboles and their conductor Léo Warynski are joined by scenographers and directors Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul to dedicate a captivating musical and visual spectacle to him.

Reservation
2026

November

Friday, November 13 2026 – 8:00 pmAnother LookL'Archipel, Scène nationale de Perpignan

By playing on the hypnotic repetition of floating motifs, minimalist music offers a fascinating sonic experience. This is the case with Another Look at Harmony, a sumptuous work by the American Philip Glass, the last part of which, for choir and organ, draws on references to Gregorian chant. Renowned interpreters of the music of our time, Les Métaboles and their conductor Léo Warynski are joined by scenographers and directors Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul to dedicate a captivating musical and visual spectacle to him.

Reservation

January

Friday, January 16 2025 - 08:00 pmAnother Look / Philip GlassCité musicale - Metz

By playing on the hypnotic repetition of floating motifs, minimalist music offers a fascinating sonic experience. This is the case with Another Look at Harmony, a sumptuous work by the American Philip Glass, the last part of which, for choir and organ, draws on references to Gregorian chant. Renowned interpreters of the music of our time, Les Métaboles and their conductor Léo Warynski are joined by scenographers and directors Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul to dedicate a captivating musical and visual spectacle to him.

Reservations
2025

December

Thursday, December 18 2025 - 08:00 pmAnother LookPhilharmonie de Paris

Fifty years ago, Another Look at Harmony placed American composer Philip Glass at the forefront of the minimalist movement. Following an album released in March, Les Métaboles present a staged concert version of his final evening.

Composed one year before Einstein on the Beach and eight years before Akhnaton—two operas previously conducted by Léo Warynski—Another Look offers a heady experience: repetitive writing and references to medieval Gregorian chant intertwine in a hypnotic dialogue, both minimalist and profusely rich.

Singular by nature, the American composer's score is also unique in the rarity of its concert performance. Léo Warynski and Les Métaboles do it double justice by bringing it to the stage and in the scenography of Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul, in the spirit of this porosity between the arts specific to the 1970s. An interior journey where the circle is matrix and law, a journey through time ultimately outside of time.

Reservation
Wednesday, December 17 2025 - 8:00 pmAnother LookPhilharmonie de Paris

Fifty years ago, Another Look at Harmony placed American composer Philip Glass at the forefront of the minimalist movement. Following an album released in March, Les Métaboles present a staged concert version of his final evening.

Composed one year before Einstein on the Beach and eight years before Akhnaton—two operas previously conducted by Léo Warynski—Another Look offers a heady experience: repetitive writing and references to medieval Gregorian chant intertwine in a hypnotic dialogue, both minimalist and profusely rich.

Singular by nature, the American composer's score is also unique in the rarity of its concert performance. Léo Warynski and Les Métaboles do it double justice by bringing it to the stage and in the scenography of Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul, in the spirit of this porosity between the arts specific to the 1970s. An interior journey where the circle is matrix and law, a journey through time ultimately outside of time.

Reservation

August

Saturday, August 29 2025 - 03:00 amAnother Look (concert version)Festival de la Chaise Dieu

In the bustling New York of the 1970s, the young Philip Glass, then in search of an innovative style, would find in the choral music of the Italian Renaissance the source of a polyphony rich in astonishing modernism. From there would be born an emblematic, minimalist and repetitive style, in which the listener dives, gets lost, finds himself and ends up transformed. And who better than Léo Warynski and his magnificent choir Les Métaboles to immerse us in this music, making it resonate with a new work by Andrea Basily?

Reservation
Saturday, August 2025 - 09:00 pmAnother LookRencontres musicale de Vézelay

A hypnotic work, Another Look at Harmony is an extraordinary experience of time and listening, both rooted in its multiple references to the music of the past and enhanced by the intact modernity of Philip Glass's repetitive style. Following a recording at the Cité de la Voix, Léo Warynski extends his passionate exploration of the American composer's work through a uniquely staged concert, in homage to the dialogue between the arts.

Reservation

May

Thursday, May 15 2025 - 07:00 pmAnother Look - Philip GlassLa Filature, scène nationale de Mulhouse

Another Look at Harmony by Philip Glass, performed by the ensemble Les Métaboles under the direction of Léo Warynski, combines with the visual creation of Céline Diez and Clément Debailleul, offering a concert show where music and image interact in an unprecedented way and offers a immersive and sensory experience.

The title, Another Look at harmony, invites us to rethink harmony by combining auditory and visual perceptions. This project is a free poetic reverie around the infinitely large and the infinitely small, exploring the cyclical dimensions of time so dear to Glass's work. Far from being limited to a simple illustration, the visual creation develops a dialogue with the music, broadening the listener's horizon through a sensitive and renewed perception.

 “It is not enough to hear the music, you must also see it,” wrote Stravinsky… The music becomes a painting, the image a melody, thus creating a form of total art where the senses intermingle, offering the viewer a journey through sound and visual landscapes.

Reservation